Technique · Winter evenings, before the season opens.
Tying flies you will actually fish
A short list of patterns that covers most of a season, and what to get right on each.
Proportion beats materials
A Hare's Ear tied with the wrong fur but the right proportions will out-fish a perfect-material fly tied too fat. The hook shank divided in thirds — tail, body, thorax — is the single rule that makes a nymph look like food rather than a caterpillar. Measure it against the hook, not against a photograph.
Tie three sizes of six patterns
A box of eighteen flies — a Pheasant Tail, a Hare's Ear, a Zebra Midge, an Elk Hair Caddis, a Comparadun and a Woolly Bugger, each in #12, #16 and #20 — will fish almost any river in this ledger on the day you arrive. Depth and size are adjustable; a box with 200 patterns in one size is not.
Tie for the water you fish
The reason local patterns exist is that they encode a specific river's light and colour. A fly that works on a clear alpine river is often too subtle for a peaty Norwegian salmon river, and vice versa. Before you tie a season's worth of anything, tie six of it in different weights and colours and fish them against each other on your home water.
Rivers in the ledger where this applies
White River, Arkansas
Ozark foothills below Bull Shoals Dam, Arkansas, United StatesA tailwater you fish from a boat, where the generation schedule is the tide table.
brown · rainbow · cutthroat
Apr · May · Jun · Sep · Oct · NovDavidson River
Pisgah National Forest, North Carolina, United StatesThe most accessible trout water in the southern Appalachians, and surprisingly technical.
brown · rainbow
Apr · May · Sep · OctPenns Creek
Centre and Snyder Counties, Pennsylvania, United StatesWhere the Green Drake hatch is a public event and the whole valley closes for a week.
brown · brook · rainbow
Apr · May · Jun · OctLetort Spring Run
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, United StatesThe hardest small stream in America, and the one that invented the terrestrial fly.
brown
Apr · May · Jun · OctFarmington River
Litchfield County, Connecticut, United StatesNew England's most reliable tailwater, with a catch-and-release TMA that fishes in January.
brown · brook · rainbow
May · Jun · Jul · Sep · OctPere Marquette River
West-central Michigan, United StatesA national-forest river where fall steelhead run on autumn rain, not on a dam schedule.
brown · steelhead · rainbow
Apr · May · Sep · Oct · Nov