Technique · Whenever fish are visibly rising.
Matching a hatch
Working out what the fish are eating, then deciding whether to match it or to break the rules.
Three questions in order
Ask: what stage are they taking (dun, emerger, spinner, pupa)? What size? What colour? In that order, because stage matters most and colour least. A fish taking spinners will ignore a perfect dun of the right size; a fish taking #18 olives will usually take a #16 in the wrong colour before it takes a #12 in the right one.
The net beats the box
The fastest way to answer all three questions is to catch one fish and look at what is in its throat. On a hatch you do not understand, deliberately catch one fish on a general pattern — a Hare's Ear or a Pheasant Tail — and then match exactly what comes out. This is not cheating; it is entomology.
When to ignore the hatch
During a heavy hatch, the biggest fish in the river often refuse to compete in the drift line and instead sit under the emergence, eating the nymphs and emergers that never make it. Fishing a small emerger 30 cm below the surface during a blanket hatch catches the fish everyone else is walking past.
Rivers in the ledger where this applies
White River, Arkansas
Ozark foothills below Bull Shoals Dam, Arkansas, United StatesA tailwater you fish from a boat, where the generation schedule is the tide table.
brown · rainbow · cutthroat
Apr · May · Jun · Sep · Oct · NovDavidson River
Pisgah National Forest, North Carolina, United StatesThe most accessible trout water in the southern Appalachians, and surprisingly technical.
brown · rainbow
Apr · May · Sep · OctPenns Creek
Centre and Snyder Counties, Pennsylvania, United StatesWhere the Green Drake hatch is a public event and the whole valley closes for a week.
brown · brook · rainbow
Apr · May · Jun · OctLetort Spring Run
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, United StatesThe hardest small stream in America, and the one that invented the terrestrial fly.
brown
Apr · May · Jun · OctFarmington River
Litchfield County, Connecticut, United StatesNew England's most reliable tailwater, with a catch-and-release TMA that fishes in January.
brown · brook · rainbow
May · Jun · Jul · Sep · OctPere Marquette River
West-central Michigan, United StatesA national-forest river where fall steelhead run on autumn rain, not on a dam schedule.
brown · steelhead · rainbow
Apr · May · Sep · Oct · Nov